Perch vs. Cod vs. Walleye: Which Fish Should You Order?

Choosing a fish dinner should be enjoyable. But when a menu offers several kinds of white fish, it is fair to ask: What actually makes them different?

The short answer is flavor, texture, and the kind of bite you enjoy. Lake perch offers gentle sweetness and smaller fillets. Cod delivers mild flavor and larger flakes. Walleye brings a delicate, sweet flavor in a more substantial freshwater fillet. All three have their fans, and preparation makes a difference, too.

At The Deck Down Under in Jerome, Michigan, our fried perch is our number-one seller. Our cod gives guests another fish-dinner favorite, and we serve walleye during Lent each year. Walleye is a seasonal offering and is not currently on our menu.

We hand-cut our fish and prepare our coatings in-house, including hand-dredging our fried perch. We never buy fish that arrives already battered. That hands-on approach also gives you choices: fried, baked, or pan-seared. Tell us what you enjoy, and we can help you choose your dinner and preparation.

What is the difference between perch, cod, and walleye?

Fish	Typical flavor	Texture and eating experience	Choose it if you enjoy
Lake perch	Mild and gently sweet	Smaller fillets with a firm, fine-flaked bite	A traditional Great Lakes fish fry
Cod	Mild and clean	Larger flakes and a substantial, tender bite	A familiar white-fish dinner
Walleye	Mild, sweet, and delicate	Fine flakes in a larger freshwater fillet	A seasonal freshwater favorite

These are general descriptions, not a scoring system. The cut, cooking method, seasoning, and your own preferences all influence which fish becomes your favorite.

What does lake perch taste like?

Lake perch has a mild, slightly sweet flavor and white flesh that holds together while flaking easily. It offers enough character to be interesting without needing heavy seasoning. Minnesota Sea Grant identifies lake perch as yellow perch and describes its sweet flavor and firm, flaky flesh. Learn more about yellow perch from Minnesota Sea Grant.

Its smaller fillets make it particularly enjoyable fried: you get crisp edges and tender fish in the same bite. A coating should complement that balance, allowing the fish to remain the reason you ordered it.

Our fried lake perch is our number-one seller at The Deck Down Under. We hand-dredge it in-house and serve it with your choice of house-made cocktail sauce, house-made remoulade, or tartar sauce.

Yes, tartar sauce has plenty of loyal supporters. We simply believe it should have some competition.

Are lake perch and ocean perch the same fish?

No. Lake perch and ocean perch are different fish, not one species living in two different places.

In the Great Lakes region, lake perch generally means freshwater yellow perch. Ocean perch is a market name used for certain saltwater rockfish or redfish. For example, Pacific ocean perch is a rockfish, identified by NOAA Fisheries as Sebastes alutus. See NOAA’s Pacific ocean perch profile.

The shared word “perch” can make a menu confusing, but the distinction matters when you are expecting a particular fish dinner.

How do their flavor and texture compare?

Lake perch is known for mild sweetness and a firm, delicate flake. Ocean perch varies with the species sold under that name. NOAA describes Pacific ocean perch as having a delicate, nutty flavor, fairly firm flesh, and a fine flake. Pacific ocean perch seafood facts.

Ocean perch can make an enjoyable meal. It simply is not interchangeable with the lake perch many Michigan diners have in mind. Nor does being an ocean fish automatically make it taste stronger or saltier.

If a menu only says “perch,” asking “Is that lake perch or ocean perch?” is a useful question. At The Deck Down Under, our perch dinner features lake perch.

What does cod taste like?

Cod is a good starting point for someone who enjoys a mild fish dinner. Its appeal is a clean flavor and larger flakes that separate into satisfying bites. NOAA describes Atlantic cod as mild and clean-tasting, with large flakes; flavor varies somewhat between Atlantic and Pacific cod. Read NOAA’s Atlantic cod seafood profile.

Compared with the smaller fillets of lake perch, cod generally gives you a thicker piece of fish. That changes the experience on the plate even when both are prepared the same way.

For a guest choosing between our cod and perch dinners, our practical advice is simple: think about whether you want smaller fillets with plenty of crisp edges or a more substantial, flaky bite.

What does walleye taste like, and when do you serve it?

Walleye is a freshwater favorite with a mild, sweet flavor and delicate flakes. Its fillets can offer more thickness than the small perch fillets familiar to fish-fry fans. It works well with simple preparations that let its flavor come through. SeafoodSource’s walleye profile describes its flavor, texture, and versatility.

At The Deck Down Under, we serve walleye during Lent each year. It is not currently on our menu, so think of it as a seasonal dinner to watch for when our Lenten offerings return.

Our current menu is the place to start when planning a visit. You do not have to wait for Lent to enjoy a fish dinner here.

Which fish should I order if I do not like a strong fish flavor?

All three belong in the conversation for someone who prefers mild fish. There is no universal winner because people notice flavor differently, and seasoning, sauces, and preparation can change the experience considerably.

Our suggestion is to tell your server what you have enjoyed before. “I like a mild flavor but want something crispy” is more helpful than feeling you need to know every species on the menu.

If you are exploring a fish for the first time, try a bite before adding sauce. Then add a little and see what you prefer. You will learn more about your own tastes than you would by covering the whole dinner before the first forkful.

Why does preparing fish in-house matter?

The fish species is only part of the dinner. The person preparing it matters, too.

At The Deck Down Under, we hand-cut our fish and handle the coating in our own kitchen. We never purchase pre-battered fish. Our fried perch is hand-dredged in-house, so preparing your dinner involves more than opening a package and dropping a finished product into a fryer.

A dredge and a batter are different approaches. A dredge typically coats the surface with a dry mixture, while a batter is a wet mixture that forms a crust during cooking. Either can be made well. Thickness, seasoning, and cooking technique determine how the coating works with the fish underneath.

Our goal is a coating that belongs with the fish. You ordered a fish dinner, after all. You should not need an excavation team to find it.

Preparing fish ourselves also means we can offer a different approach when you are not in the mood for fried food.

Should I order my fish fried, baked, or pan-seared?

Each method offers something different. The right choice depends on what sounds good to you.

Fried fish: for crispness and contrast

Frying gives you the contrast between a crisp coating and tender fish. It is the choice when the crunch is part of what you are craving. Coating and cooking need to work together so the outside is enjoyable without overwhelming the inside.

Baked fish: for a gentler preparation

Baking allows the fish to cook without a fried crust. It is a good choice when you want to focus on the fish itself and the seasonings served with it. The finished dish still depends on how it is prepared, including any butter, oil, or sauce.

Pan-seared fish: for browned flavor

Pan-searing uses direct contact with a hot pan to develop a browned surface. It gives you a different kind of flavor and texture from either baking or deep-frying, with the result depending on the cut and thickness of the fish.

We can prepare our cod or lake perch fried, baked, or pan-seared. Have another preference? Tell your server how you like your fish, and we will help you find the right preparation.

What sauce should I choose with fried perch?

Our fried perch comes with a choice of house-made cocktail sauce, house-made remoulade, or tartar sauce.

House-made cocktail sauce is worth trying if it is usually something you save for shrimp. Try it with a bite of your fish before deciding that tartar gets the job automatically.

House-made remoulade gives you another option from our kitchen. If you have never tried it with your fish dinner, this is a good place to start.

Tartar sauce remains a classic choice, and there is nothing wrong with knowing exactly what you like.

We suggest dipping as you go so you can choose how much sauce you want and enjoy the coating’s texture.

Where can I enjoy a fish dinner near Jackson and the Irish Hills?

The Deck Down Under is in Jerome, Michigan, on US 12, welcoming guests from Jackson, Brooklyn, the Irish Hills, Hillsdale, and the surrounding lake communities.

Our Michigan fish fry is part of what we do throughout our regular Tuesday-through-Saturday service. Join us for our number-one-selling fried perch, choose cod, or ask about a baked or pan-seared preparation. Watch for walleye during Lent.

We open at 11 AM, and takeout is available with drive-thru pickup.

Still deciding? Start with the current menu. Tell us what you like, and we will help with the rest.

The Deck Down Under11303 E. Chicago Rd, Jerome, MI 49249517-900-9213

Make a reservationOrder online